Skip to main content

A decline in crime statistics does not necessarily mean that children are safer.

From a child protection perspective, the crime statistics released this morning are deeply concerning. While we acknowledge reductions in some categories of violent crime, we must not allow percentages and national averages to overshadow the lived realities of children who continue to experience rape, abuse, violence, exploitation and murder.

The most disturbing figure is that 4,362 children were identified as rape victims in just three months – July to September 2026. That translates to approximately 47 children a day, based on the cases in which police were able to verify the victims’ ages.

This is not simply a crime statistic. It represents children whose childhoods have been violated, whose sense of safety may have been shattered, and whose trauma may have lifelong consequences.

The challenges and discrepancies we cannot ignore

  1. A decrease in reported sexual offences does not mean children are safer.

Reported sexual offences declined by 2.7%, yet 9,908 rape cases were recorded. Of the 9,705 cases where victims’ age and sex could be established, 4,362 were children. A decline in reported cases must never be interpreted as evidence that the problem is diminishing at the same pace. Children often remain silent because of fear, shame, threats, grooming, dependency on the perpetrator, family pressure, or concern that they will not be believed.

  1. There are gaps in the data that need to be explained.

Of the 9,908 rape cases recorded, age and sex could be verified in 9,705 cases. This leaves 203 cases without that verified breakdown. Similarly, of the 5,590 murders recorded, victim age and sex were established in 5,549 cases, leaving 41 cases without those details.

These gaps matter. We need to understand who our victims are, particularly whether they are children, how old they are, where they are being victimised, who is perpetrating these crimes, and what patterns of vulnerability emerge. Data is not merely about recording a crime; it should guide prevention, resource allocation and interventions that protect the most vulnerable.

  1. We must interrogate inconsistencies in the reporting of the figures.

There appears to be a discrepancy in reporting the reduction in murders. The Minister’s statement refers to more than 1,600 fewer murders compared with the corresponding period last year, while reporting elsewhere indicates that murders declined from 5,794 to 5,590 – a difference of 204. These figures do not reconcile, and this needs clarification rather than being allowed to pass without scrutiny. Accuracy and consistency are fundamental to public trust in crime statistics.

South African Government+2

  1. Crime statistics reflect reported and recorded crime – not the full extent of victimisation.

We must remember that the statistics capture crimes that reach the police and are recorded. They cannot fully reflect children who never disclose, those whose families prevent them from reporting, those who are threatened into silence, those who are failed at the point of disclosure, or those whose abuse is misidentified as a behavioural, family or disciplinary problem.

For child protection practitioners, this is one of the greatest concerns. The absence of a police report is not the absence of abuse.

  1. We cannot police our way out of child abuse.

Police visibility and prosecution are essential, but child abuse requires a much broader, integrated response. We need stronger prevention in schools and communities, accessible psychosocial services, properly trained professionals, effective child protection systems, swift investigation, accountability, and long-term therapeutic support for children and their families.

A child who has disclosed abuse must not be left navigating a fragmented system, repeatedly recounting traumatic experiences, waiting months for assistance, or falling between the cracks of government departments.

The 149 children murdered must not disappear into the national murder figure

The murder statistics indicate that 149 children were murdered during the reporting period where victims’ age and sex could be established. Every one of these deaths represents a child whose right to life, protection and safety was extinguished.

We need to interrogate the circumstances surrounding these murders. Were these children killed in domestic violence incidents? At the hands of caregivers? Through community violence, gang activity, neglect or other circumstances? We need more than aggregate numbers. We need analysis that identifies risk factors, patterns and opportunities for intervention before children die.

My message as a child protection practitioner

South Africa cannot celebrate a reduction in crime while thousands of children continue to be raped, abused and murdered. Every percentage point of decline must be measured against the reality of the lives still being destroyed.

The 4,362 children identified as rape victims in this quarter should force us to confront the uncomfortable truth that our children remain profoundly unsafe. We cannot become desensitised to these numbers. Behind every statistic is a child, a family, a trauma and a system that has a responsibility to respond.

We also need to interrogate the discrepancies, gaps and limitations in the data. Reliable statistics are critical because they determine where resources are allocated, which interventions are prioritised and whether government is responding to the actual risks children face.

Our responsibility cannot begin when a child is raped or murdered. It must begin long before the crime – in our homes, schools, communities, parenting, early intervention, safeguarding systems and the way we confront perpetrators.

Children cannot be expected to carry the burden of protecting themselves from adults, systems and communities that are failing them.

We need to move beyond recording the tragedy of child abuse to preventing it. We need a country where protecting children is not simply a policy commitment, a commemorative message or a statistic in a quarterly report, but a lived reality.

The real measure of progress is not merely whether crime decreases. It is whether fewer children are being harmed, whether children are safer in their homes, schools and communities, and whether a child who cries for help is met by a system that responds with urgency, compassion and accountability.